Mr P's Tires

One of the worst car experiences that I have ever had! Did not balance the NEW tires so I had to go back. When I went for the balancing part of the job (that should have been done when the NEW tires were mounted) they totally ruined the wheels. Scratches and dents. I’ve reached out to them several times thinking surely they aren’t going to do nothing. Well they will do nothing. See photos. Ladies beware.

I had a slow leak in one tire. They repaired that, checked all of the other tires, their air pressure, and filled them with air... for $20. I am a woman of a "particular age"and I have never felt taken advantage of at this establishment. I have bought tires here over the years at a fair price and got quality tires. This is a no frills place and I believe they have a lot of integrity. Located on the NW corner of 76th and Florist...a couple blocks north of Silver Spring in Milwaukee. Update(11/17/23): I had 2 tires with "slow leaks" repaired. They replaced the faulty valve stems, filled all tires with air AND gave me a nice discount for being a loyal customer. They don't "upsel" anything unnecessary. I still highly recommend them!👍

When I first pulled in, I thought to myself, "what did I get myself into coming here?" The place looks like a junkyard. Tires (old and new) everywhere- in the parking lot, inside the garage, and in the lobby/customer waiting area! I'm not sure what's going on- lack of storage? Disorganized? Management? The place just did not look professional. That said, I didn't come here to mingle or to enjoy a cup of tea. Despite its unprofessional appearance, they really were professional and they got me in and out of there rather quickly. Even though it didn't bother me all that much (maybe because i was having used tires installed and my wheels were already in not so good shape), one thing I would like to point out is that they didn't put alot of emphasis on detailing of customers' wheels. They didn't bother cleaning up all the grease used during the installation of my tires onto the wheels. (Zoom into picture)This may ot may not be an issue for people with expensive, fancy wheels that just got cleaned. Overall, it wasn't a bad place. I actually would go back. Especially since they install used tires as well as being opened until 4pm central time. Good luck

Consistently closes early as if people don’t need tired between 4-5 pm. Considering this is the time most who work first shift are getting off I don’t understand why employees would be allowed to leave early. I’m sitting in the parking lot with a flat and 5 other cars have drove in the lot looking for service I see there is a response to this review I have photos of them not being there at 4:40 and also took pictures of the several other cars in the parking lot looking for services.. an employee even mention that they consistently close early

Mr. P's has been the place I have gone for tires since the 90's. Tire prices fit my working woman's budget. They are always respectful and kind. I take my tires there when they have a nail or a slow leak. I have always been VERY happy with their service and have taken many of my family and friends to them. The staff is hard working and knowledgeable. Great Milwaukee Tire Place!!!